Featured Post

PINNED POST. CLICK HERE: Keeping these 3 videos of officer-involved domestic violence fatalities on top. Blog best navigated from computer.

Officer-Involved Domestic Fatalities - 1 Officer-Involved Domestic Fatalities - 2 [WA] Tragedy Will Occur If They Don't Have ...

Custom Search
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query gundersen. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query gundersen. Sort by date Show all posts

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

[CA] Ex-Chief Gundersen already in & back out of jail - for violating another court order

..."Mr. Gundersen has already been found guilty of violating a court order... " [Judge Bruce] Watson said he would expect someone who left town with a sentencing date of Wednesday to appear back in town on Tuesday. Watson questioned whether Gundersen's failure to appear was due to arrogance and feelings of being above the law... Darcie Seal, the alleged victim in the recent case against Gundersen, was sitting beside Gundersen prior to the hearing. She left the courtroom immediately after Watson's ruling...

(Previous Gundersen entries on the blog here)

GUNDERSEN POSTS BAIL, RELEASED FROM CUSTODY

The Times-Standard
10/28/2008
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen posted bail and was released from Humboldt County jail Friday, just hours after being remanded by a Humboldt County judge for failing to appear at a Wednesday court hearing. Gundersen, who was convicted last month of battery and weapons charges, was free after posting $50,000 bail but -- after Gundersen missed his sentencing hearing Wednesday -- Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson remanded him back into custody, ordering his bail increased to $200,000. The former police chief's sentencing hearing has been rescheduled to Nov. 21, although a defense motion for a retrial is expected to be heard before then. [Full article here]

GUNDERSEN A NO-SHOW AT HEARING
The Eureka Reporter, CA
Oct 22 2008, 3:53 PM
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen didn’t show for a Wednesday court hearing and will have a $200,000 bench warrant issued if he doesn’t show for a Friday hearing... Gundersen’s attorney Russel Clanton said he was traveling by car from Newport Beach, Calif., where he was visiting his ailing mother... Gundersen, 54, was released from the Humboldt County jail Sept. 29 after Judge W. Bruce Watson reduced his bail from $1.25 million to $50,000. He’d been in jail since his Feb. 8 arrest. A jury acquitted Gundersen Sept. 24 of all 24 counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant and one count of attempting to dissuade a witness. The jury found him guilty of 11 counts of battery – a finding based on nude photographs Gundersen allegedly took of his wife Darcie Seal without her permission – illegally possessing a machine gun and silencer and violating a court order to not contact Seal. [Full article here]

GUNDERSEN BACK IN JAIL, SENTENCING PUSHED BACK TO NEXT MONTH
The Eureka Reporter, CA
Oct 24 2008
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen is back in jail today, after a judge agreed with the prosecution that Gundersen had no credible reason for missing his sentencing on Wednesday... Humboldt County Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson set Gundersen's bail at $200,000 and scheduled his sentencing for Nov. 21. Darcie Seal, the alleged victim in the recent case against Gundersen, was sitting beside Gundersen prior to the hearing. She left the courtroom immediately after Watson's ruling... Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos argued that Gundersen's thought process doesn't matter and asked the court to remand him so the probation report can be completed. "Mr. Gundersen has already been found guilty of violating a court order," he said. "He assumed the court would continue the matter regardless of whether there was good cause. Watson said he would expect someone who left town with a sentencing date of Wednesday to appear back in town on Tuesday. Watson questioned whether Gundersen's failure to appear was due to arrogance and feelings of being above the law. [Full article here]

BLUE LAKE TRYING TO SHUT DOWN GUNDERSEN'S CITY E-MAIL
The Times-Standard
Donna Tam
10/25/2008
Blue Lake city staff have been trying -- with no luck so far -- to shut down an e-mail account started and apparently still used by their former Police Chief David Gundersen. Staff have been trying to cancel the account “bluelakepd@aol.com” for the last few weeks, since it was brought to their attention. The account was originally set up to function as the e-mail address for the entire department, and is paid for by the city. Originally started by Gundersen, he is the only one who has access to the account, and, according to more than one recipient, is still sending mail from that address. Mayor Pro Tem Marlene Smith said a resident told her about receiving an e-mail from the account, and a similar report was received by the Times-Standard... City Clerk Karen Nessler said the e-mail service provider, America Online, is refusing to shut down the account under Gundersen's name without the correct codes needed to cancel the account - codes that only Gundersen has... [Full article here]

'ARROGANCE': JUDGE SENDS GUNDERSEN BACK TO JAIL FOR MISSING HEARING
The Times-Standard
John Driscoll
10/25/2008
Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson sent David Gundersen back to jail Friday after the former Blue Lake Police chief skipped a Wednesday sentencing hearing... Watson on Friday expressed concern that Gundersen's absence on Wednesday suggests he might be a flight risk, and decided to remand him to jail and set bail at $200,000. ”I wonder if it is in fact arrogance, a contempt for the proceeding or an attitude that what applies to others does not apply to him -- if that's the case, Mr. Gundersen should be remanded,” Watson said. “Obviously, the laws apply to all equally.” Watson agreed to delay Gundersen's sentencing to Nov. 21. Gundersen turned to his wife Darcie Seal -- whose initial allegations of rape made to investigators led to his arrest Feb. 8 -- and frowned. He then immediately turned away and was led out of the courtroom by a bailiff. The jury in September found Gundersen not guilty on charges of raping his spouse with the use of an intoxicant and attempting to dissuade the victim of a crime, but convicted the former police chief on 11 misdemeanor counts of battery, violating a court order and illegally possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer. Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, has said he intends to seek a new trial... Gallegos pointed out that a jury had convicted Gundersen of violating a court order, and that his failure to appear Wednesday is the second time he had disregarded the court's direction. Watson chose to take a hard line with Gundersen. ”Quite frankly, I haven't heard anything very persuasive regarding Mr. Gundersen's absence other than that he wasn't there, and that's disturbing,” Watson said. “To me, I have a hard time getting beyond the idea of arrogance." [Full article here]

Sunday, February 17, 2008

[CA] Chief Gunderson 12-count cop-on-cop spousal rape charges

Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's ex-wife - a legal office assistant in the Sheriff's office - claimed in 1999 court records that Gundersen - her then husband - drugged her for unwanted sex. Now he faces 12 counts of raping his CURRENT wife - a Blue Lake Police sergeant - while SHE was drugged. He also faces charges on 3 acts [allegedly] committed while in custody. One is threatening the witness, his wife - caught on a phone call - and planning places to hide. Gundersen is being kept in jail for safety of the victim and because he carries a firearm. The chief's attorney, Arcata attorney Russell Clanton: "Frankly I think the position is that the state has put their nose into the bedroom of Chief Gundersen and his current wife"... He said the couple engaged in conduct that "has been misinterpreted and in fact has been exaggerated," and is of an intimate nature.

Articles over the last week:

Blue Lake police chief arrested for alleged rape
The Times-Standard
John Driscoll
02/10/2008
[Excerpts] Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, 53, was arrested in McKinleyville Friday on suspicion of rape. Gundersen was being held at the Humboldt County Jail on $500,000 bail, according to jail personnel Saturday... [Humboldt County District Attorney Paul] Gallegos said Gundersen was arrested on suspicion of rape of a spouse, but he did not know the underlying facts. The charge listed on the arrest list is for suspicion of rape of a spouse "where a person is prevented from resisting by any intoxicating or anesthetic substance, or any controlled substance, and this condition was known, or reasonably should have been known, by the accused." Gundersen's wife is a sergeant on the Blue Lake police force...

No charging decision made in Gundersen case, says DA
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson and Karen Wilkinson
02/12/2008
[Excerpts] District Attorney Paul Gallegos said Monday that his office is investigating allegations of spousal rape made against the Blue Lake police chief that span a couple of years, but no charging decisions have been made... "The information we have is this is not a one-time occurrence," [Humboldt County District Attorney Paul] Gallegos said... District Attorney's Office Chief Investigator Mike Hislop said there is always a worry in cases involving domestic allegations that emotions may run high and people may do irrational things. In this case, where Gundersen carries a firearm, Hislop said extra caution was warranted. Hislop said Gundersen was called Friday night and told the Humboldt County Drug Task Force was going to issue a search warrant in Blue Lake, and officers wanted to meet him at the substation to go over the plan. "When he drove up and walked in, we put our hands on his shoulder and told him, 'Dave, we're got an arrest warrant for you,'" Hislop said. "We tried our best to make sure it was low key, and nobody got hurt, and this was the best way to do it... Gundersen's wife, a Blue Lake police sergeant, has been on leave for several months, Blue Lake City Manager Wiley Buck said. It's unclear whether the circumstances of her leave are work-related, Buck said... Gallegos said after Gundersen was taken into custody, a search warrant was served on his McKinleyville home that led to the seizure of a "lot of stuff"...

In tense meeting, council puts off action on jailed police chief
The Times-Standard
Donna Tam
02/13/2008
[Excerpts] To the dismay of residents, the Blue Lake City Council said Tuesday night they could not take any action regarding the arrest and jailing of the city's police chief until its next meeting... Gundersen is currently on paid administrative leave, said City Manager Wiley Buck, bringing groans from the public during a meeting that got tense at times. "Where are we sending the check? To the jail?" asked resident Patty Meger...

Video excerpts - Chief Gundersen's attorney:
"...I believe that the issues that the district attorney are attempting to have evolve into a CRIMinal matter, in fact are intimate family issues best played out in a family law court... I would just simply say that it's our opinion at this stage that the state is intervening into the private lives of uh citizens at their most private moments. We consider that to be wholly inappropriate..."


Gallegos sticks to his guns regarding investigation into Blue Lake police chief (with video)
The Times-Standard
John Driscoll
02/13/2008
[Excerpts] Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's attorney said Tuesday that a bitter custody dispute is likely the genesis of his arrest on suspicion of spousal rape. Arcata attorney Russell Clanton said that Gundersen's current wife told him that she's not a victim, and that she's completely supportive of her husband. She did not attend the press conference and attempts to contact her were unsuccessful. Clanton said that he believes it was Gundersen's ex-wife who alleged his current wife was raped while intoxicated or drugged. Clanton said the chief intends to plead not guilty at his arraignment... "Frankly I think the position is that the state has put their nose into the bedroom of Chief Gundersen and his current wife," Clanton said. District Attorney Paul Gallegos strongly disagreed with Clanton's take. He said Tuesday that he believes Gundersen's current wife is the alleged victim, that she first reported the alleged acts and that his investigators have been in contact with her in recent days. "If we don't have a victim, it seems we wouldn't have probable cause to issue an arrest warrant," Gallegos said. Gundersen's ex-wife works as a legal office assistant at the Humboldt County Sheriff's Office. The office received the initial call from the victim, according to Gallegos, and then forwarded the information and turned the investigation over to the district attorney... Clanton said a 12-year-old son from Gundersen's previous marriage has been staying exclusively with Gundersen and his current wife for about six months... He said the couple engaged in conduct that "has been misinterpreted and in fact has been exaggerated," and is of an intimate nature...

Gundersen hit with 12 counts of rape
The Times-Standard
John Driscoll and Thadeus Greenson
02/14/2008
[Excerpts] Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen was arraigned on 12 counts of spousal rape on Wednesday, along with additional charges of coercing a witness... Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all charges. The claims stretch back to March 2007, with the last instance of alleged rape while the victim was intoxicated or anesthetized occurring on Feb. 7. That's the day before 53-year-old Gundersen was arrested in McKinleyville. A bail hearing was set for today. "We make decisions based on the evidence we have," said Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos. Gallegos said the multiple rape charges all stem from the same victim... Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton said that he's been told that the information he has received from the investigation is only a small part of what has been collected by the district attorney's office. But he added that his stance has not changed regarding the chief's innocence... Clanton said Tuesday that he believed the claims arose from a custody dispute between Gundersen and his ex-wife. He said that the intimate conduct between Gundersen and his current wife, which is the focus of the investigation, was exaggerated and misinterpreted. Gallegos said that the ex-wife is not involved in the current case, and is not a victim.... Along with the other charges is a claim that Gundersen violated a court order on Feb. 9, and on the same day was in possession of a controlled substance without a prescription. Gallegos was unsure if that possession charge stemmed from an incident that occurred while Gundersen was in custody...

Gundersen custody battle goes back 10 years
The Times-Standard
02/14/2008
[Excerpts] Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen faced allegations of raping his ex-wife as part of a heated custody dispute nearly 10 years ago, court records show. Gundersen's ex-wife claimed in 1999 court records that her then husband put drugs in her food or drink so she couldn't resist his unwanted sexual demands. Gundersen now faces 12 counts of raping his current wife while she was drugged or intoxicated. He pleaded not guilty to all criminal charges filed on Wednesday... Gundersen's ex-wife, who works for the Humboldt County Sheriffs Office as a legal office assistant, is represented by Arcata attorney Joan Gallegos, the wife of Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos...

Judge denies police chief's release
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson
02/15/2008
[Excerpts] Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles denied a request Thursday to release Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen on his own recognizance, citing the seriousness of the charges against him. Gundersen, who appeared in court clad in a red jumpsuit with his hands cuffed in front of him, faces 12 separate counts of spousal rape... He also faces three other charges allegedly committed while in custody: Attempting to prevent a victim from reporting a crime, willfully violating a court order and being in possession of a controlled substance without a prescription. Gundersen pleaded not guilty to all charges on Wednesday. Russell Clanton, Gundersen's attorney, requested that his client be released on his own recognizance because of his long history in law enforcement, his desire to clear his name, his lack of a criminal record, the fact he owns a home in McKinleyville and is responsible for the care of his two teenage children... "I would point out to the court that the alleged victim approached my office to say she in no way fears the defendant's release," Clanton said. Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos opposed Clanton's request, arguing that Gundersen poses an imminent threat to the public, due to the serious nature of the charges and his access to firearms. Gallegos also argued that Gundersen's conduct in custody shows he is a flight risk and could pose a danger to the victim. Gallegos said recorded phone conversations made while Gundersen was in jail show he was making threats to the victim and discussing possible hiding places with a registered sex offender... When Clanton asked the court to reconsider Gundersen's bail, which is set at $500,000, Miles advised Clanton that if she were to reconsider the bail, she would go by the court's bail schedule, which would raise it to $715,000. Clanton retracted the request...

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

[CA] She was afraid she'd die if she didn't lie says ex-attorney for Chief Gundersen's wife

DAVID GUNDERSEN'S WIFE FEARED THE FORMER BLUE LAKE POLICE CHIEF WOULD KILL HER IF SHE TESTIFIED... ”SHE WAS PETRIFIED,” GRIEGO CONTINUED, ADDING THAT HE PROBABLY SPOKE TO HER ABOUT 100 TIMES OVER TWO MONTHS. “SHE WAS SHAKING AND IN TEARS MOST OF THE TIME I TALKED TO HER”... GUNDERSEN FACES TWO DOZEN COUNTS OF RAPING SEAL WHILE SHE WAS UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT, AS WELL AS CHARGES OF VIOLATING A COURT ORDER, ATTEMPTING TO DISSUADE THE VICTIM OF A CRIME AND ILLEGALLY POSSESSING A SUBMACHINE GUN AND A PISTOL WITH AN ATTACHED SILENCER...

Previous entries:
  • [CA] Chief Gunderson 12-count cop-on-cop spousal rape charges - ...Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's ex-wife - a legal office assistant in the Sheriff's office - claimed in 1999 court records that Gundersen drugged her for unwanted sex. Now he faces 12 counts of raping his CURRENT wife - a Blue Lake Police sergeant... He also faces charges on 3 acts committed while in custody. One is threatening the witness, his wife - caught on a phone call - and planning places to hide. Gundersen is being kept in jail for safety of the victim and because he carries a firearm...
  • [CA] Update on Chief Gunderson's wife-rape charges & guns, guns, guns - ...His attorney, Russell Clanton, contends that seeds of trouble were planted by the chief's former wife, now a Humboldt County sheriff's office dispatcher, who he says has plotted to poison Gundersen's relationship with his current spouse...
  • [CA] Cop dv victims in even more danger (and even more likely then to recant) - ...experts say it's not uncommon for victims to change their mind on pressing charges, or reinterpreting what they've said... They may have hope that the person they love will change... But the No. 1 reason, Lemon said, is the fear of retaliation... Those women are in more danger because the police will usually protect their own”...
  • [CA] Trial: Chief Gundersen's wife now says it was all lies - The trial for Blue Lake Police Chief Gundersen picks up again on August 25th. Here are excerpts from recent news, including a list that I extracted from the articles, given as the reasons why the Chief's wife Darcie now says she lied...
GUNDERSEN’S EX-WIFE TAKES STAND
The Eureka Reporter
John C. Osborn josborn@eurekareporter.com
Aug 26 2008
[Excerpts] Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen’s ex-wife testified Tuesday about details of their custody battle and allegations that she formulated a plan to have him arrested to benefit her in the custody decision. She gave details about allegations of rape during their marriage that she made against her husband and her interactions with Darcie Seal, who is the alleged victim in this trial and Gundersen’s current wife. It is The Eureka Reporter’s policy to not disclose the name of sexual assault victims, but Darcie Seal has asked both the court and media to use her real name. Gundersen is charged in this trial with 24 counts of alleged spousal rape with an intoxicant, along with five other charges, including two related to illegal firearms... Although the allegations of rape came out during their on-and-off eight-year custody battle, she testified that she never filed criminal charges because she didn’t want to put her children through such a proceeding. Gundersen’s ex-wife testified that starting in 2006, Seal confided to her that Gundersen was having non-consensual sex with her... This morning, there will be a brief hearing to decide whether Diane Wetendorf, an expert in police-perpetrated domestic violence, will be allowed to testify for the prosecution... [Full article here]

[What reason could they have for NOT letting Diane testify, I wonder aloud.]

Two articles from yesterday:


GUNDERSEN'S WIFE SPENDS DAY 4 ON STAND
Times-Standard, CA
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com
08/26/2008
[Excerpts] The WIFE of former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen testified Monday that when she lied to investigators the day of her husband's arrest, she felt they were just holding another “Dave-bashing party.” ”It's not the first time everyone sat around bashing Dave,” Gundersen's wife, Darcie Seal, testified about the Feb. 8 interview with investigators. She referred to them as friends of Gundersen's ex-wife and said she answered their questions sarcastically and never wanted her husband arrested... GUNDERSEN FACES TWO DOZEN COUNTS OF RAPING SEAL WHILE SHE WAS UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT, AS WELL AS CHARGES OF VIOLATING A COURT ORDER, ATTEMPTING TO DISSUADE THE VICTIM OF A CRIME AND ILLEGALLY POSSESSING A SUBMACHINE GUN AND A PISTOL WITH AN ATTACHED SILENCER. He has pleaded not guilty and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail. Taking the stand for the fourth day, Seal's testimony ranged from her contact with Gundersen since his arrest to why her story has changed dramatically from her testimony during Gundersen's preliminary hearing. With Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton continuing his cross examination, Seal testified that she didn't fear her husband before her Feb. 8 interview with investigators, but that they convinced her Gundersen was homicidal and suicidal. Seal said she also told members of the District Attorney's Office that her Feb. 8 statements to law enforcement were false, and that she had even written District Attorney Paul Gallegos a letter on Feb. 25 saying as much. Seal later read the letter before the court. It said she had been coerced by investigators, didn't want to file a criminal complaint and didn't fear her husband... Because of that and the fact that Seal has recanted her earlier accusations against her husband and - mirroring a trend in many domestic abuse cases - Clanton directly asked Seal if she'd been trained as a law enforcement officer on the psychology of victims of domestic abuse and she said she had been. ”Do you have an opinion about whether or not you are a victim of domestic abuse?” Clanton asked. ”Yes -- I am not,” Seal testified... [Full article here]

ATTORNEY: GUNDERSEN'S WIFE FEARED SHE'D BE KILLED FOR TESTIMONY
The Times-Standard, CA
Attorney: Gundersen's wife feared she'd be killed for testimony
Thadeus Greenson
08/27/2008
[Excerpts] David Gundersen's wife feared the former Blue Lake police chief would kill her if she testified against him during his rape trial, her former attorney testified Tuesday. ”She was terrified - she believed this client was going to kill her if she testified,” attorney Patrik Griego said Darcie Seal told him while he represented her in the two months leading up to Gundersen's preliminary hearing. ”She was petrified,” Griego continued, adding that he probably spoke to her about 100 times over two months. “She was shaking and in tears most of the time I talked to her”... She testified that she confronted Gundersen. ”He asked me if I was wearing a wire, and I said 'no,'” she testified, adding that Gundersen then admitted to giving her sleeping pills and having sex with her while she slept. “He said he loved me so much and that's how he expressed his love. That's the only way he could do it.”... Dave Morey, of the sheriff's office where she works, what Seal told her but did not consider filing a police report because she didn't have any proof that Seal's allegations were true. Gundersen's ex-wife also testified that Seal asked her if she had told law enforcement, was happy to hear that she had and that Seal often expressed homicidal feelings. ”Every time I got together with her she talked about killing him,” Gundersen's ex-wife said. “She said she was homicidal”... [Attorney] Griego and Michael Crowley, who represented Seal during Gundersen's preliminary hearing, testified that Seal never told them the allegations against her husband were false, which she claimed to have done while testifying Monday... After Gundersen's trial concluded for the day Tuesday, Gallegos confirmed there is an ongoing investigation into Seal's conduct, but declined to go into specifics... [Full article here]

Monday, March 19, 2012

[CA] THE JOKE IS ON LADY JUSTICE: Felonies REVERSED for former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen

[Former Blue Lake Police Chief David] Gundersen faced more than two dozen criminal counts - a jury convicted him of 14 charges. Of those, only a misdemeanor conviction of violating a court order stands today... Gundersen has been cleared of all major charges... eight felonies, including spousal rape, witness tampering, possession of a machine gun and a silencer. He was also charged with three misdemeanors, including violation of a court order, possession of a controlled substance and unauthorized disclosure of information... On Thursday, March 15, a state appeals court overturned the two [remaining] felony convictions. Gundersen had contended that Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles failed to adequately instruct the jury...


[Gundersen is also the former chief of Trinidad Police Department and also worked for the Adelanto Police Department]

PREVIOUS POSTS:
  • February 17, 2008 - CA] Chief Gunderson 12-count cop-on-cop spousal rape charges - ...Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's ex-wife - a legal office assistant in the Sheriff's office - claimed in 1999 court records that Gundersen drugged her for unwanted sex. Now he faces 12 counts of raping his CURRENT wife - a Blue Lake Police sergeant... He also faces charges on 3 acts committed while in custody. One is threatening the witness, his wife - caught on a phone call - and planning places to hide...
  • June 4, 2008 - [CA] Update on Chief Gunderson's wife-rape charges & guns, guns, guns - ...His attorney, Russell Clanton, contends that seeds of trouble were planted by the chief's former wife, now a Humboldt County sheriff's office dispatcher...
  • August 14, 2008 - [CA] Cop dv victims in even more danger (and even more likely then to recant) - ...experts say it's not uncommon for victims to change their mind on pressing charges, or reinterpreting what they've said... They may have hope that the person they love will change... But the No. 1 reason, Lemon said, is the fear of retaliation... Those women are in more danger because the police will usually protect their own”...
  • August 17, 2008 - [CA] Trial: Chief Gundersen's wife now says it was all lies - The trial for Blue Lake Police Chief Gundersen picks up again on August 25th. Here are excerpts from recent news, including a list that I extracted from the articles, given as the reasons why the Chief's wife Darcie now says she lied...
  • August 27, 2008 - [CA] She was afraid she'd die if she didn't lie says ex-attorney for Chief Gundersen's wife - David Gundersen's wife feared the former Blue Lake Police Chief would kill her if she testified... ”she was petrified,” Griego continued, adding that he probably spoke to her about 100 times over two months. “She was shaking and in tears most of the time I talked to her”...
  • October 28, 2008 - [CA] Ex-Chief Gundersen already in and back out of jail - for violating another court order... He also faces charges on 3 acts [allegedly] committed while in custody. One is threatening the witness, his wife - caught on a phone call - and planning places to hide. Gundersen is being kept in jail for safety of the victim... The chief's attorney, Arcata attorney Russell Clanton: "Frankly I think the position is that the state has put their nose into the bedroom of Chief Gundersen and his current wife"...

RECENT NEWS:

GUNDERSEN'S FELONIES REVERSED; appeals court finds court improperly instructed 2008 jury
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson
03/18/2012 02:39:44 AM PDT
 A California appellate court has reversed a pair of 2008 felony firearms convictions against David Gundersen, leaving the possibility that the former Blue Lake Police chief will face another trial... On Sept. 24, 2008 - after a two-month trial in which Gundersen faced more than two dozen criminal counts - a jury convicted him of 14 charges. Of those, only a misdemeanor conviction of violating a court order stands today... Ultimately, in the 2008 trial, Gundersen faced two-dozen charges of spousal rape with the use of an intoxicant, charges of illegally possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer, and violating a court order... Gundersen was sentenced to four years probation and time served. On Thursday, the appeals court ruled that Watson erred in not fully instructing the jury that exceptions apply to the firearms offenses that allow law enforcement officers to possess the weapons within the scope of their duties. Watson didn't, the appellate ruling stated, explicitly tell the jury it was the prosecution's burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Gundersen's case did not fit those exceptions... [Full article here]

EX-BLPD CHIEF GUNDERSEN CLEARED OF ALL FELONIES
The Arcata Eye
Kevin L. Hoover
Friday, March 16, 2012
[Excerpts] Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen has been cleared of all major charges first filed against him in 2008. Gundersen was originally charged with eight felonies, including spousal rape, witness tampering, possession of a machine gun and a silencer. He was also charged with three misdemeanors, including violation of a court order, possession of a controlled substance and unauthorized disclosure of information. The rape charge and two of the misdemeanors were dismissed. After a jury trial in September, 2008, Gundersen was found guilty of the submachine gun and silencer possession felonies, plus a misdemeanor charge of violating a court order. He was also found guilty of 11 misdemeanor charges of battery over surreptitious photographs taken of his ex-wife and BLPD colleague, Darcy Seal, when she was asleep. But those charges were later tossed out due to the statute of limitations. The single misdemeanor charge of violating a court order was not appealed, and still stands. Gundersen was sentenced to two concurrent two-year terms, which were suspended. He was placed on four years probation and sentenced to 354 days in county jail but got credit for time served, which accounted for all but a few days of the sentence. He appealed the two weapons charges in December, 2008. On Thursday, March 15, a state appeals court overturned the two felony convictions. Gundersen had contended that Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Marilyn Miles failed to adequately instruct the jury about exemptions in state law that allow regular, salaried, full-time police officers to possess machine guns and silencers. He claimed that his possession the Heckler & Koch MP5 submachine gun and silencer were within the scope of his duties... The Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office could re-file the charges... [Full article here]

NO FELONIES. 





FROM OLDER NEWS,  RECALLING THE ORDEAL OF   JANE DOE 1 AND 2


JANE DOE 1, 
Blue Lake police sergeant Darcie Seal, then-wife of Gundersen, who asked later in case that her name be used publicly
  • Apr 24 2008 - ..."Jane Doe 1" finished testimony today, clarifying why she didn’t report the alleged non-consensual sex by Gundersen... Doe 1 made it clear that it was never her intention to press charges on Gundersen. She also said she "felt coerced" by the several people at Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office to make statements she would otherwise not have made during a seven-hour interview. Doe 1 had fears about coming forward about alleged non-consensual sex that occurred while she and Gundersen dealt with marital problems, starting in late 2005... Doe 1 testified that she feared for her safety when talking with HCSO, but her fears "became worse because of what was said to me during the interview." At one point, Doe 1 recalled being told that Gundersen would take her "fishing." Doe 1 said she interpreted it as "he was going to take me fishing and hurt me." During the second interview with investigators from the district attorney’s office, Doe 1 testified that they claimed she committed felonies that she hadn’t. She said she feared prosecution and going to prison. "You’d like to avoid going to prison wouldn’t you?" Gundersen’s attorney Russell Clanton said. "Of course," she said...
  • May 6, 2008  - ...At the city council meeting, City Attorney Richard Platz also announced the resignation of the police department's remaining supervisor, Sgt. Darcie Seals. Seals had a claim against the city, which was settled by the city's insurance company. The settlement cost the city $5,000, who said he could not reveal any details about the claim because it is a personnel matter...
  • Aug 14 2008 - During a tense day of testimony Thursday at David Gundersen’s trial, wife Darcie Seal recanted almost all of her previous statements she made that referred to wrongdoing by her husband... [District Attorney Paul] Gallegos asked Seal if she thought investigators would take her allegations as a joke, as she testified that she tried to tell everyone she was being sarcastic... "What part of the joke made you cry?" 
WHILE RECANTING, REASONS DARCIE GAVE COURT FOR LYING:
  • As a "cure” to get him out of the house.
  • To get him out of her life. She says she "didn't think it was at all serious."
  • She had emotional stress from raising four kids & being a cop.
  • She had mental stress from marital problems.
  • Rape claim was just her being sarcastic.
  • She was set up to lie by her husband's ex-wife as a part of a plot.
  • Had no idea she was being recorded
  • Investigators convinced her it was rape
  • She was just "pissed off and talking... I say things I don't mean."


JANE DOE 2, 
woman Gundersen said he'd train into police work, started a relationship and moved in with. According to Jane 2 she didn't know his divorce was not finalized and did not know until records were produced at trial, that she was never actually employed by the police department - though she participated in police actions.
  • Apr 22 2008 - The first person to testify in the hearing was "Jane Doe No. 2," who alleges that Gundersen raped her after forcing her into their bedroom in March 1999... She said Gundersen offered her an undercover job with the Trinidad Police Department, where he was chief at the time... "He offered to train me"... she testified that at some point she and Gundersen started dating and eventually moved in together. In March 1999, she testified, Gundersen forced her to have sex after an argument... Jane Doe No. 2 said that three children were in the house that night – her child and two of Gundersen’s children... Jane Doe No. 2 testified, Gundersen grabbed her, forced her into the bedroom, tore up her clothes and raped her. She said she reported the incident to the Eureka Police Department because she feared the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office would do nothing ... As far as she knew, she said, nothing happened regarding her report...
  • Apr 22 2008 - ...At first, testimony revolved around Doe 2’s employment at two local police departments... Doe 2 testified that she worked at both the Trinidad and Blue Lake Police Departments. While working with TPD, she testified that she joined in several operations with other agencies. One assignment she described involved TPD, BLPD and the Arcata Police Department... According to public record requests made by The Eureka Reporter, the real name of Doe 2 does not show up in both TPD and BLPD employment records... 
  • Apr 24 2008 - ...Lt. Len Johnson talked with Doe 2, according to court documents. When interviewed by Hislop, Johnson vaguely recalled the encounter, but couldn’t remember specifics...


WORTH REPEATING:

EPD reportedly didn't follow up on 1999 rape report
The Times-Standard
John Driscoll and Thadeus Greenson
04/22/2008
Jane Doe 2 testified Monday at Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's preliminary hearing that she reported to the Eureka Police Department in 1999 that Gundersen raped her, but the department never followed up on the claims.

Under the questioning of District Attorney Paul Gallegos, Doe testified that Gundersen forcibly raped her in March 1999 while they were living together with plans of marrying. Doe said she reported the rape to both a local advocacy group and EPD.

Doe testified that she contacted EPD because she knew Gundersen's then wife worked at the Humboldt County Sheriff's Office, which would have had jurisdiction over the alleged McKinleyville rape, and she consequently feared the department would not follow up on her report.

A Computer Aided Dispatch call record contained in Gundersen's court file, indicates that Doe called EPD at about 2:30 p.m. on March 26, 1999. Len Johnson, now a lieutenant with the department, spent about 45 minutes with Doe, according to the record, but did not file a report.

In testimony Monday, Doe said Johnson told her he would follow up on the matter.

”He said at the very least his chief would talk to then-Chief Gundersen, and they would investigate it,” Doe testified, adding that she never heard back from EPD on the matter.

A District Attorney's Office Investigation Report in Gundersen's file indicates that Chief Investigator Mike Hislop contacted Johnson and asked him about Doe's call.
Advertisement

”He reviewed the (Computer Aided Dispatch) report and could not recall any specifics or what (Doe) had contacted him about,” the report states.

Johnson declined to comment for this story, saying the subject is part of an ongoing case in which he expects to be subpoenaed to testify.






police officer involved domestic violence oidv intimate partner violence ipv abuse law enforcement public safety lethal firearms exemption repeat hx recant recanting teflon california state politics]

Sunday, August 17, 2008

[CA] Trial: Chief Gundersen's wife now says it was all lies

The trial for Blue Lake Police Chief Gundersen picks up again on August 25th. Here are excerpts from recent news, including a list that I extracted from the articles, given as the reasons why the Chief's wife Darcie now says she lied, telling the court she was drugged, raped, and photographed many, many times by her husband.

...[Darcie] Seal and Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, have alleged that investigators detained, coerced, bullied and browbeat Seal into making rape allegations during the Feb. 8 interview. A portion of the interview shown to the jury Wednesday seemed to contradict some of those allegations...

[Darcie is an ex police sgt with Blue Lake Police, and Chief Gundersen's ex-wife works at the McKinleyville Sheriff's substation.]

DARCIE NOW SAYS SHE LIED...
  • BECAUSE SHE HAD EMOTIONAL STRESS FROM RAISING FOUR KIDS & FROM HER BEING A COP.
  • BECAUSE SHE HAD MENTAL STRESS FROM MARITAL PROBLEMS.
  • BECAUSE RAPE CLAIM WAS JUST HER BEING SARCASTIC.
  • BECAUSE SHE WAS SET UP TO LIE BY HER HUSBAND'S EX-WIFE AS A PART OF A PLOT.
  • BECAUSE IT WAS A "CURE" TO GET HIM OUT OF THE HOUSE.
  • BECAUSE SHE WANTED TO HAVE HIM OUT OF HER LIFE.
  • BECAUSE SHE WANTED TO GET HIM OUT OF HER LIFE.
  • BECAUSE SHE "DIDN'T THINK IT WAS AT ALL SERIOUS."
  • BECAUSE SHE HAD NO IDEA SHE WAS BEING RECORDED.
  • BECAUSE INVESTIGATORS CONVINCED HER IT WAS RAPE.
  • BECAUSE SHE "WAS JUST PISSED OFF AND TALKING".
  • BECAUSE SHE SAYS THINGS SHE DOESN'T MEAN.
  • SHE CRIED WHILE SHE LIED THAT SHE WAS RAPED BECAUSE SHE WANTED TO LEAVE.
  • SHE LIED BECAUSE SHE WASN'T IN THE "RIGHT STATE OF MIND."
  • BECAUSE SHE HAD JUST COME BACK FROM HER PSYCHIATRIST.
  • BECAUSE SHE WAS TELLING INVESTIGATORS WHAT THEY WANTED TO HEAR.
  • BECAUSE... SHE SAYS SHE DOESN'T KNOW WHY SHE LIED.
  • SHE LIED BECAUSE HER RECOLLECTIONS WERE FUZZY.
ALLEGED VICTIM TALKS ABOUT EMOTIONAL STATE
The Eureka Reporter
By John C. Osborn josborn@eurekareporter.com
Aug 15 2008
Darcie Seal testified Friday at the trial of her husband, former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, that as a result of emotional and mental stress stemming from years of mothering children, police work and marital problems, lying to investigators about allegations of rape was seen as a "cure” to get him out of the house. While under cross-examination by Gundersen’s attorney, Russell Clanton, Seal described the details of events that led up to her interview with investigators on Feb. 8, resulting in Gundersen’s arrest that day for alleged spousal rape. Seal, who asked The Eureka Reporter to use her real name instead of the "Jane Doe” court designation, requested the court to do the same during the proceedings. Gundersen is charged with 24 counts of alleged spousal rape with an intoxicant, along with five other charges, including two related to illegal firearms... [Full article here]

Gundersen's wife: I didn't think he'd be arrested
Times-Standard, CA
08/15/2008 0
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's wife testified today that she lied about being raped to investigators on the day of her husband's arrest out of a desire to have him out of her life. Under questioning by Gundersen's defense attorney Russell Clanton, Darcie Seal said she had no idea why she was called to the Humboldt County Sheriff's Office on Feb. 8, but in hindsight believes it was part of a plot by Gundersen's ex-wife to get him to leave the county and secure full custody of their children... He [Gundersen] is in custody on $1.25 million bail. The charges stem from Seal's Feb. 8 interview by investigators, in which she told them that over the course of years she'd been repeatedly raped by Gundersen while she slept. Seal, a former Blue Lake police sergeant, has since recanted her statements... "I didn't think it was at all serious," Seal said of the February interview, despite the fact that she was being questioned by senior members of law enforcement... [Full article here]

GUNDERSEN JURY SEES INTERVIEW VIDEO
Gundersen's wife takes the stand, says she lied to investigators
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com
08/14/2008
The wife of former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen testified Wednesday in her husband's spousal rape trial that Gundersen never had sex with her against her will and that she lied to investigators... Seal testified that Gundersen never engaged in nonconsensual sex with her and that she was being "sarcastic" when she told investigators he had on the day of her husband's arrest... [District Attorney Paul] Gallegos then halted her testimony to show the jury a videotape of her Feb. 8 interview with investigators. Before the video was shown, Seal testified that she only agreed to meet investigators at the Sheriff's station in Eureka to discuss an appropriate police response in the event that "things got heated" between her and Gundersen. She testified that she was under emotional duress and answered investigators' questions sarcastically because she felt she was speaking with the friends of Gundersen's ex-wife, who works at the McKinleyville Sheriff's substation. "I had no idea I was being recorded or that it was a serious matter," Seal testified, also saying investigators did not allow her to leave. Seal testified that she lied to investigators. She only testified that her husband had engaged in nonconsensual sex with her at his preliminary hearing because investigators had convinced her it was rape... Gallegos later asked Seal if she was also being sarcastic when she sent her husband an Aug. 16, 2007, e-mail accusing him of lying to her, using her and raping her. "I was just pissed off and talking," Seal responded. "I say things I don't mean." Seal and Gundersen's attorney, Russell Clanton, have alleged that investigators detained, coerced, bullied and browbeat Seal into making rape allegations during the Feb. 8 interview. A portion of the interview shown to the jury Wednesday seemed to contradict some of those allegations. The hour-and-a-half-long interview, approximately an hour of which was shown in court Wednesday, begins with Seal asking Sheriff's Office Lt. Dave Morey, Detective Troy Garey and Sgt. Wayne Hanson if the interview is being recorded. They respond that it is. Seal sat in the courtroom's first row Wednesday, about 10 feet behind her husband, as the prosecution played the video in which Seal repeatedly uses the word "rape" to describe Gundersen's acts, even saying that he'd confessed about a week earlier that he'd been raping her while she was asleep... She says numerous times that she considers it rape, at one point even saying she told Gundersen "people go to prison for this for a long time." In the video, she also told the investigators Gundersen had threatened to kill her and had recently told her he wanted to "put a gun to his head"... Seal conveys fears to investigators regarding what impact Gundersen's arrest would have on his children, on him and on her... The jury is expected to view the remainder of the video when the trial resumes today... [Full article here]

DA GRILLS ALLEGED VICTIM ON STAND
The Eureka Reporter
By John C. Osborn josborn@eurekareporter.com
Aug 14 2008
During a tense day of testimony Thursday at David Gundersen’s trial, wife Darcie Seal recanted almost all of her previous statements she made that referred to wrongdoing by her husband. Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos continually questioned Seal about precise statements she made to investigators and during the preliminary hearing, only to find that she said all those past statements were false... Seal recanted a long list of allegations she made against Gundersen, including that he raped her and that he was more aroused sexually when she was sleeping... [District Attorney Paul] Gallegos asked Seal if she thought investigators would take her allegations as a joke, as she testified that she tried to tell everyone she was being sarcastic... "What part of the joke made you cry?" Gallegos pressed her about the taped interview. "I wanted to leave," Seal said. "I was confused." Seal testified that when she walked into the Feb. 8 interview with investigators, she wasn’t in the "right state of mind" and felt emotional as she had just come back from her psychiatrist... [Full article here]

GUNDERSEN'S WIFE SAYS SHE LIED TO INVESTIGATORS, ON STAND AT PRELIM
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson
08/15/2008
David Gundersen's wife testified Thursday she lied to investigators and during her husband's preliminary hearing, while taking the stand on the fourth day of the former Blue Lake police chief's spousal rape trial... Thursday's proceedings began with the jury viewing the last minutes of the investigators' Feb. 8 interview with Gundersen's wife, Darcie Seal... Seal testified that investigators repeatedly told her she was not free to leave the interview, despite her requests. During the hour-and-a-half-long videotaped interview shown to the jury, Seal is never seen asking to leave. She also testified at various points Thursday that she was simply repeating things Gundersen's ex-wife had told her, that she was telling investigators what they wanted to hear and that she was angry with Gundersen at the time. "As a police officer, you are aware that giving false evidence is a crime?" Gallegos asked. "Yes," Seal responded. Gallegos also questioned Seal about her testimony during Gundersen's preliminary hearing, walking her through transcripts of the proceedings and repeatedly asking her if she remembered answering his questions, and if she was honest. She testified that she didn't remember, or only vaguely remembered, many parts of the interview and preliminary hearing, saying she was under a lot of stress... "I felt stuck," Seal testified.... Gallegos asked her who she told that to, but Seal said she could not recall.. [Full article here]
GUNDERSEN'S WIFE AGAIN DENIES RAPE
Times-Standard, CA
John Driscoll jdriscoll@times-standard.com
08/16/2008
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's wife testified Friday that her desire to have her husband out of her life prompted her to lie about being raped to investigators on the day of his arrest. Under questioning by Gundersen's defense attorney Russell Clanton, Darcie Seal said she had no idea why she was called to the Humboldt County Sheriff's Office on Feb. 8, but in hindsight believes it was part of a plot by Gundersen's ex-wife to get him to leave the county and secure full custody of their children... During the videotaped interview seen by the jury earlier this week, Seal claims Gundersen raped her and photographed her naked without her consent while she was sleeping, and when confronted, didn't stop the practice. In court, Clanton asked her why she said that. ”How did that come to be, Darcie?” Clanton said. ”I don't know,” Seal answered. Seal also said that she was at an emotional and mental low point at the time, and that her recollection of the events of that February day were fuzzy... ”I told them it was about getting Dave to move,” Seal said. “I never thought it was going to end up in Dave's arrest"... ”There was so much going on that I felt abandoned,” Seal said... ”How would you describe your emotional well-being during 2007, Darcie?” Clanton asked. ”I was a mess,” she answered. The trial is on break until Aug. 25. [Full article here]

Topix Forums:

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

[CA] Update on Chief Gunderson's wife-rape charges & guns, guns, guns

[CA+Blue+Lake+Police+Chief+David+Gundersen_2008.jpg]
...His attorney, Russell Clanton, contends that seeds of trouble were planted by the chief's former wife, now a Humboldt County sheriff's office dispatcher, who he says has plotted to poison Gundersen's relationship with his current spouse...

Previous entry:
[CA] Chief Gunderson 12-count cop-on-cop spousal rape charges - Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's ex-wife - a legal office assistant in the Sheriff's office - claimed her then husband - drugged her for unwanted sex. Now he faces 12 counts of raping his CURRENT wife - a Blue Lake Police sergeant - while she was drugged. He also faces charges on 3 acts [allegedly] committed while in custody. One is threatening the witness, his wife - caught on a phone call... The chief's attorney, Arcata attorney Russell Clanton: "Frankly I think the position is that the state has put their nose into the bedroom of Chief Gundersen and his current wife"... He said the couple engaged in conduct that "has been misinterpreted and in fact has been exaggerated," and is of an intimate nature.

POLICE CHIEF'S ARREST IS A MAJOR JOLT TO SLEEPY NORTHERN CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY OF BLUE LAKE
The head of the tiny force, accused of drugging and sexually assaulting his wife, collected enough guns at headquarters to arm a small platoon. He also allegedly kept unregistered guns at home.
Los Angeles Times
By Eric Bailey eric.bailey@latimes.com
June 4, 2008
[Excerpts] Just beyond the reach of the North Coast fog, this little community of 1,150 basked until recently under the protection of a police force of just four officers. Four officers packing 31 submachine guns. The Blue Lake police force was armed on a par with a big-city SWAT team. And no Blue Lakers knew until Police Chief David Gundersen's life began to very publicly unravel. In February, Humboldt County sheriff's deputies arrested Gundersen on suspicion of crimes in his own bedroom. Prosecutors have charged him with 33 counts, alleging that the chief repeatedly drugged his wife, a Blue Lake police sergeant, and forced her to have sex. As investigators dug deeper into his private life, they discovered Gundersen's guns. At home, he had a weapons cache that included a machine gun and a James Bond-style pistol with a silencer, both unregistered. At police headquarters, he had enough weaponry to arm a small platoon... In all, investigators seized 111 weapons -- nearly a quarter of them from his home. The chief behind bars, the police force mothballed, City Hall under fire -- this was a seismic scandal for a bucolic town tucked peacefully in the Humboldt County redwoods... Gundersen arrived in 1999 after a short run in nearby Trinidad and a controversial stint in the high desert San Bernardino County city of Adelanto, where he was accused of theft... Earlier this month, Gundersen went to court in a jail jumpsuit. He pleaded not guilty to all counts. The trial is scheduled for June 30. If convicted, Gundersen could face up to life in prison. For now, he remains behind bars in lieu of $1.25-million bail. His attorney, Russell Clanton, contends that seeds of trouble were planted by the chief's former wife, now a Humboldt County sheriff's office dispatcher, who he says has plotted to poison Gundersen's relationship with his current spouse. The result, he said, has been a "witch hunt" that has prosecutors, the media and disgruntled Blue Lakers piling on... In the meantime, critics are questioning why the City Council didn't step in more decisively long ago. Council members respond that they knew nothing of the gun cache until they read about it in the paper... [Full article here]

Selected excerpts from news since the last entry:

JANE DOE "FELT COERCED" INTO MAKING STATEMENTS
The Eureka Reporter
By JOHN C. OSBORN josborn@eurekareporter.com
Apr 23 2008 · Updated: Apr 24 2008
[Excerpts] ..."Jane Doe 1" testified that she "felt coerced" by officials working in the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office into making a statement about non-consensual sex with Gundersen... Gundersen, currently the police chief for the Blue Lake Police Department, may face trial on suspicion of 19 charges, including 12 counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant, one count of kidnapping to commit another crime and possession of a machine gun.. At the end of Tuesday’s session, Humboldt County District Attorney Paul Gallegos questioned Doe 1 about nude photographs found on Gundersen’s computer hard drive taken without her consent while sleeping... Jane 1 testified that she never filled out a report with the HCSO about the non-consensual sex, and felt "lured" by the HSCO to talk about it. She said it was never her intention to have Gundersen prosecuted and the only reason she is testifying is because she is under subpoena by the District Attorney’s Office... Doe 1 also brought up Margaret Gundersen, David Gundersen’s former wife, who also works at the HCSO. She felt Margaret Gundersen orchestrated the interview because of a custody battle she was engaged in with David Gundersen, and wanted the interview to end... Jane Doe 2 also finished her testimony, most of which revolved around her mental health prior to the alleged rape. Doe 2 testified that her memory is "pretty much wiped" because of medication she took for post traumatic stress disorder following the alleged rape... [Full article here]

DOE 1: ‘I DON’T THINK I WOULD HAVE EVER COME FORWARD’
The Eureka Reporter
By JOHN C. OSBORN josborn@eurekareporter.com
Apr 24 2008
[Excerpts] ..HCSO Detective Troy Garey testified about contact between Gundersen and Doe 1 after an Emergency Protective Order was signed by Doe 1. Doe 1 said in previous testimony that she didn’t realize what the order entailed until after she signed it, and wanted it reversed. The order prohibited Gundersen from direct and third-party contact in any way with Doe 1, and is the source of two of the 19 charges against him. Garey testified that on Feb. 9, Gundersen contacted Doe 1 and asked her not to testify and to contact Cox, Hislop and/or Gallegos to have the charges dropped. Garey monitored phone conversations with Gundersen to make sure the EPO was enforced. There were also three letters intercepted by Garey and jail staff in April. Toward the end of the day, testimony by Chief DA Investigator Michael Hislop focused on why there wasn’t a report from EPD about Doe 2’s visit on March 26, 1999... When interviewed by Hislop, Johnson vaguely recalled the encounter, but couldn’t remember specifics... [Full article here]

JUDGE FINDS PROBABLE CAUSE FOR DAVID GUNDERSEN
By JOHN C. OSBORN , The Eureka Reporter
Apr 30 2008 · Updated: May 1 2008
[Excerpts] After five days of testimony during the preliminary hearing for Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen, the Humboldt County Superior Court held Gundersen to stand trial to 19 charges Wednesday... Gundersen will go to trial on charges that include suspicion of 12 counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant, possession of a machine gun and possession of a firearm with a silencer. He is being held at the Humboldt County jail in Eureka with a $1.25 million bail... Prior to closing statements, District Attorney Investigator Steve Dunn presented testimony to support charges of possession of a machine gun and possession of a firearm with a silencer — two firearms were found in Gundersen’s home... Law enforcement officers found approximately 111 firearms, including 25 found at Gundersen’s residence...
1. Spousal rape with an intoxicant — 12 counts
2. Prevent/dissuade witness from reporting
3. Disobey court order/process
4. Possession of a controlled substance
5. Rape by force
6. Disclosure of information/record without permission
7. Possession of a machine gun
8. Possession of a firearm with a silencer
[Full article here]

GUNDERSEN PLEADS NOT GUILTY TO 33 CHARGES
By JOHN C. OSBORN , The Eureka Reporter
May 12 2008
[Excerpts] Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen pleaded not guilty to the 33 charges now against him during his arraignment Monday. The Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office added 14 new charges against Gundersen based on testimony during his preliminary hearing in April. “Jane Doe 1” testified that Gundersen engaged in non-consensual sex with her once a month for about two years... The District Attorney’s Office also filed a count of suspicion of kidnapping to commit rape – pertaining to “Jane Doe 2” – despite Judge John F. Feeney’s ruling on April 30 that no kidnapping took place. Feeney modified the charge to rape by force. Gallegos said he thinks there is enough evidence to warrant the kidnapping charge... [Full article here]

Monday, September 29, 2008

[CA] Ex-Chief Gundersen beats 24 felonies, guilty on 11 charges of battery

The protection order is lifted and he's probably out of jail now.

...A JURY OF 7 WOMEN AND 5 MEN ACQUITTED HIM OF 24 [FELONY] COUNTS OF SPOUSAL RAPE WITH AN INTOXICANT AND ATTEMPTING TO DISSUADE A WITNESS... BUT THE JURY CONVICTED THE FORMER POLICE CHIEF ON 11 MISDEMEANOR COUNTS OF BATTERY, VIOLATING A COURT ORDER AND ILLEGALLY POSSESSING A SUBMACHINE GUN AND A PISTOL WITH A SILENCER...

(Previous entries on the blog here)

GUNDERSEN TO BE RELEASED FROM JAIL TONIGHT
The Eureka Reporter
Sep 29 2008
Humboldt County Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson reduced former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's bail from $1.25 million to $50,000 and Gundersen's attorney Russell Clanton said that Gundersen will be posting bail and be released from jail tonight. The decision comes less than a week after a jury of seven women and five men acquitted him of 24 counts of spousal rape with an intoxicant and attempting to dissuade a witness. The jury did find him guilty of 11 counts of battery (relating to nude photographs taken of his wife Darcie Seal), two firearm-related charges and violating an emergency protective order. On Friday, Watson dismissed the emergency protective order placed on Gundersen follow his preliminary hearing in April, which prohibited him from contacting Seal... [Full article here]

LAST WEEK:


JUDGMENT: JURY ACQUITS GUNDERSEN ON RAPE CHARGES, CONVICTS ON BATTERY AND GUNS

Eureka Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com.
09/25/2008
EUREKA -- Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Ray Gundersen was acquitted of two dozen spousal rape charges in Humboldt County Superior Court Wednesday, but convicted of 11 lesser charges of battery and two charges of illegal firearms possession. A jury of seven women and five men found Gundersen not guilty on charges of raping his spouse with the use of an intoxicant and attempting to dissuade the victim of a crime, but the jury convicted the former police chief on 11 misdemeanor counts of battery, violating a court order and illegally possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer. Together, the firearms charges carry a maximum sentence of three years and eight months in state prison or a fine of $20,000. Gundersen's convictions on the 11 battery charges each carry a sentence of up to six months in jail, a fine of $2,000, or both. The 24 spousal rape counts Gundersen initially faced would have carried a sentence of 72 to 192 years in prison. Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson set an Oct. 22 date for Gundersen's sentencing. The felony firearms convictions effectively end Gundersen's career as a law enforcement officer, and the misdemeanor battery convictions would make it illegal for him to possess firearms.... It remains unclear exactly how Wednesday's verdict will translate into sentencing, as legal experts contacted by the Times-Standard said much of Gundersen's sentence will be left to the discretion of the judge... [Full article here]

GUNDERSEN'S BATTERY CONVICTIONS MAY COME UNDER FIRE
Eureka Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com
09/26/2008
Former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's 11 convictions on charges of misdemeanor battery may be tossed out in the near future, according to legal experts... battery charges are misdemeanors carrying a one year statute of limitations. Because the jury chose to convict on the battery charges in counts 1 through 11, counts that allegedly took place in January through November of 2006, it appears the statute of limitations would have run out, and that the convictions may have to be overturned as a result. "The prosecution has a real problem," said University of California Berkeley School of Law professor Franklin Zimring, adding that the defense will likely file a motion to vacate the convictions. "That means that either the jury wasn't aware of (the statute of limitations for misdemeanors), or that there's somebody brilliant on the jury who found a way to reprimand the chief without really convicting him." For his part, District Attorney Paul Gallegos said he believes the statute of limitations clock, even on misdemeanors, doesn't start running until law enforcement knows or reasonably should have known of the offense... [Full article here]

PROTECTIVE ORDER REVOKED IN GUNDERSEN CASE

Eureka Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com
09/27/2008
Humboldt County Superior Court Judge Bruce Watson revoked a court protective order Friday that forbade former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen from having any contact with his wife, Darcie Seal... The protective order had been in place since Gundersen's preliminary hearing... [Full article here]

Saturday, August 30, 2008

[CA] Cop-dv advocate & friend of Chief Gundersen's wife (Darcie) testify

...[Wife of Chief Gunderson / former Blue Lake Police Sgt. Darcie Seal's friend, Janet] Arnot also testified that she called 911 at one point in September 2001... She said she told the operator the Blue Lake police chief was trying to break into her home with her two children present. She said no one from law enforcement showed up...

[Previous blog entries here]

Expert: Domestic violence is about power, control
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson tgreenson@times-standard.com
08/29/2008
[Excerpts] David Gundersen's wife feared the former Blue Lake police chief would kill her if she testified against him, a District Attorney's Office investigator and a friend of Gundersen's wife testified Thursday. Janet Arnot, a friend of Gundersen's wife Darcie Seal, testified that Seal told her she always had a fear of drowning and that Gundersen had threatened to “take her fishing,” which Arnot said Seal took to mean that Gundersen would kill her. Seal made a similar claim to investigators during the Feb. 8 interview that led to her husband's arrest, but later testified the comments were made in jest and she never took them seriously. Gallegos asked Arnot if she thought Seal took the comment as a joke. ”No, she always took it seriously,” Arnot testified. “It frightened her -- it still frightens her”... Gundersen faces two dozen counts of raping Seal with the use of an intoxicant, as well as charges of violating a court order, attempting to dissuade the victim of a crime and illegally possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with a silencer attached. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges and remains held in the Humboldt County jail on $1.25 million bail... Before talking about the specifics of her recent conversations with Seal, Arnot made it clear she was uncomfortable doing so. ”She spoke to me in great confidence and, in answering these questions, I'm breaking her confidence and that's something that's always going to weigh heavily on my heart,” she said... Things got so bad, Arnot testified, that Seal even said she made several complaints to Blue Lake City Manager Wiley Buck ... "She told me nothing was ever done about that... It was completely ignored”... Arnot also testified that she called 911 at one point in September 2001 when Gundersen was trying to gain entry into the home she and Seal were living in at the time. She said she told the operator the Blue Lake police chief was trying to break into her home with her two children present. She said no one from law enforcement showed up... Before Arnot took the stand, the jury heard from Diane Wetendorf, who has counseled domestic violence victims since 1985. Wetendorf testified that while domestic violence can take all shapes and forms, it is always about power and control. Abusers, Wetendorf testified, often use isolation, emotional abuse, economic abuse and sexual abuse to exert constant control over their partners. Because of these factors, as well as pressures from family and religion, Wetendorf said it is very common for it to take years for a victim to come forward. And when they eventually do, Wetendorf said, it is very common for them to later recant their statements. Wetendorf said she's seen women get emergency protective orders against their violent husbands only to recant their allegations to get their husbands off the hook when the matter comes before a court. "She's going to do whatever she has to do, and if that means lying to our faces, she's going to lie to our faces,” Wetendorf said. “It's about survival.” Under cross examination, Wetendorf said she's never qualified as an expert witness before, characterized herself as a victim's advocate and said she was being paid to testify at the trial... [Full article here]

Phone calls detail wife's suspicions, hesitation to talk about alleged sex crimes
The Eureka Reporter
By Karen Wilkinson,
Aug 29 2008
[Excerpts] David Gundersen's wife would have divulged more possibly incriminating information against the former Blue Lake Police Department chief if the media wasn't reporting on the case, she told an investigator in early June. In recorded phone conversations, WHICH DARCIE SEAL WAS TOLD WEREN'T BEING TAPED, she told District Attorney's Office Investigator Wayne Cox on June 10 that she found concerning items in Gundersen's side of their garage, shed and the BLPD office. Those items included hard drives, small cameras and video tapes, which Seal indicated may contain nude photos of her taken with or without her consent. Seal also referenced newspaper articles that mentioned their sex life and said she "won't talk about it because I don't want it in the paper. To tell you the truth … I'm supposed to do that in front of everybody and the press?... I don't want everybody to know... Nobody knows what David put me through... I have been so exposed I feel like I'm the one paying and he is not."... [Full article here]

With heavy heart, Seal's friend speaks of rape allegations she heard
The Eureka Reporter
By John C. Osborn
josborn@eurekareporter.com
Aug 28 2008
[Excerpts] A longtime friend of Darcie Seal testified in former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen's trial Thursday about allegations of rape and verbal abuse Seal made to her in confidence prior to his arrest. Expert on police-perpetrated domestic violence Diane Wetendorf also explained to the jury key characteristics found in victims of that kind of violence... Janet Arnot, a friend of Seal's since 1996, prefaced her testimony explaining to the jury that Seal had talked to her about these allegations in great confidence. "In answering these questions," she said, "I break that confidence and it will weigh heavy on my heart"... As the expert on domestic violence, Wetendorf testified in general that a victim recanting her statements is one of the biggest obstacles to overcome in domestic violence cases, as well as the complexity of the issue.... "They're damned if they do (report)," Wetendorf said, "they're damned if they don't." [Full article here]

Thursday, September 4, 2008

[CA] Spousal rape-accused Chief Gundersen's submachine guns - and silencer

[All Gundersen blog entries here]

Guns take center stage in Gundersen case
The Times-Standard
Thadeus Greenson
09/04/2008
It was no secret that former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen used to drive around town with a fully automatic submachine gun in his patrol car, former Blue Lake City Manager Wiley Buck testified Wednesday. The submachine gun -- a 9 mm Heckler & Koch MP5 -- was at the center of testimony Wednesday, the 12th day of Gundersen's spousal rape trial, as one of two weapons Gundersen is charged with illegally possessing. Gundersen, who was arrested Feb. 8, currently faces two dozen counts of raping his wife, Darcie Seal, with the use of an intoxicant, as well as charges of violating a court order, attempting to dissuade the victim of a crime and illegally possessing a submachine gun and a pistol with an attached silencer. He has pleaded not guilty and remains held on $1.25 million bail... Blake Grahm, a special agent with the California Department of Justice Bureau of Firearms, testified that law enforcement agencies are required by law to register hand guns with AFS within 10 days of their acquisition, but that there is no such requirement for submachine guns, which agencies simply aren't required by law to register. District Attorney Paul Gallegos also questioned Dunn about 30 other submachine guns seized from the Blue Lake Police Department... U.S. Department of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms Senior Special Agent Nina Delgadillo told the Times-Standard in an April e-mail that the case was under review with the U.S. Attorney's Office in San Francisco, but no decision had been made on whether the office would seek federal prosecution... ”It doesn't make sense that a police officer would need a silencer in the types of duties they had”... [See full article here]

Thursday, August 28, 2008

[CA] In Chief Gundersen trial, police dv expert Diane Wetendorf can't address police dv

...Wetendorf will not be allowed to bring in her expertise in a niche field of domestic violence she has been researching for the past 10 years — that of domestic violence at the hands of a law enforcement official. Humboldt County Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson said he would not allow questions about alleged victims of domestic violence making false allegations... Darcie Seal, the alleged victim of spousal rape, has, since Gundersen’s arrest, changed her story several times...

Previous entries here.

Domestic violence expert to testify
The Eureka Reporter, CA
By JOHN C. OSBORN
Published: Aug 27 2008, 11:01 PM

Testimony by an expert in police-perpetrated domestic violence will be allowed in David Gundersen’s trial, the court ruled.

Diane Wetendorf, a longtime victim’s rights advocate versed in domestic violence, will be able to tell the jury about her opinions of common characteristics associated with victims of domestic violence.

In the narrow ruling, Wetendorf will only be allowed to answer questions about those characteristics, why victims recant previous statements and why they stay with an abuser.

Wetendorf will not be allowed to bring in her expertise in a niche field of domestic violence she has been researching for the past 10 years — that of domestic violence at the hands of a law enforcement official.

Humboldt County Superior Court Judge W. Bruce Watson said he would not allow questions about alleged victims of domestic violence making false allegations, a key point that Gundersen’s attorney Russell Clanton wanted to address as well.

“There has to be strict limitations,” he said, adding that an expert is not there to weigh on the guilt or innocence of the defendant.

The hearing turned heated at times as Clanton tried several times to question Wetendorf about that point and on biases that she, as an advocate, would be bringing into the courtroom.

“I think if an expert is going to assist a jury,” Clanton said, “it should be giving information from an origin that is not biased.”

Watson said that experts don’t have to be unbiased when on the stand.

The expert, who will be costing taxpayers $300 an hour while in court and a $100 an hour while reviewing documents, will help give the jury more insight into domestic violence.

Wetendorf testified that perpetrators of domestic violence exploit religion, children and, in the case of police officers, training and legal knowledge to make the victim comply.

“Domestic violence (is) a pattern of behaviors that one partner in a relationship uses against another partner,” she testified. “People have a hard time believing that a police officer can be a victim of domestic violence.”

When a police officer is the abuser, it makes it even more difficult for victims to speak out, as they have access to all the traditional channels of relief, such as shelters and law enforcement response, she said.

Darcie Seal, the alleged victim of spousal rape, has, since Gundersen’s arrest, changed her story several times, testifying during the trial that the allegations she made to investigators prior to his arrest were now false.

The prosecution will try and show that Seal’s recanting of previous statements are symptomatic with trauma that results from domestic abuse, while she alleges that those statements were a result of coercion by law enforcement officials.

Wetendorf is expected to testify today.

John C. Osborn can be reached at josborn@eurekareporter.com, or at 707-269-7445. [Link]
[police officer involved domestic violence oidv intimate partner violence ipv abuse law enforcement public safety recant recanted california state politics brass]

Thursday, August 14, 2008

[CA] Cop dv victims in even more danger (and even more likely then to recant)

...Those women are in more danger because the police will usually protect their own”...

Experts say victims often recant out of fear, love
Times-Standard, CA
Donna Tam/The Times-Standard
08/14/2008
As the trial of former Blue Lake Police Chief David Gundersen continues, the spotlight is aimed at his wife who seems to be giving contradictory testimony in the spousal rape case... While not commenting directly on Gundersen's case, experts say it's not uncommon for victims to change their mind on pressing charges, or reinterpreting what they've said. ”People have very mixed emotions... Some people are ready to go forward on day one, but then not ready to go a day later,” said Nancy Lemon, a lecturer at the University of California Berkeley School of Law and a domestic violence expert witness... They may have hope that the person they love will change, outside pressures from family or clergy who don't believe in divorce, financial dependence, or they want to keep a father figure for their children... But the No. 1 reason, Lemon said, is the fear of retaliation... “The fear is a really really big deal. Victims are aware that the criminal justice system can't protect them”... Lemon said the situation can be perpetuated if the abuser is in law enforcement. ”Those women are in more danger because the police will usually protect their own,” she said. Often victims will need some sort of outside support to get them through the process, Lemon said... [Full article here